The Definitive Guide on How to Build Your Perfect HCI
Hyperconverged Infrastructure (HCI) is a Software-Defined (SDx), consolidated platform that converges all the essential ‘building blocks’ of a conventional data center, which are compute, storage, networking, monitoring, and management.
HCI, or hyperconvergence, solves the common issues associated with legacy data center technology, such as elevated procurement and upkeep costs, challenging monitoring and management, and excessive power consumption.
Hyperconverged Infrastructure (HCI) relies on software-defined components that virtualize and integrate compute, storage, and networking resources to simplify their management, improve scalability, and efficiency.
Software-Defined Storage (SDS) is a modern approach to data center technology that abstracts or decouples storage resources from the underlying hardware. This opens the door to greater managerial flexibility, better power efficiency, boosted performance, and basically unlimited scalability by effectively running what used to be firmware on top of Commercial Off-The-Shelf (COTS) servers. To sweeten the deal, SDS trims down the resulting storage solution costs since commodity hardware is way cheaper than proprietary stuff, thanks to better economies of scale.
Software-Defined Compute (SDC) is another example of a modern approach to data center technology. SDC provides the management of computing resources entirely through software abstraction. It separates the handling and orchestration of physical components such as CPUs, GPUs, and memory from the actual hardware, enabling a more flexible, nearly infinitely scalable, high-performing, and fully automated computational environment. This approach significantly reduces overall costs by optimizing hardware utilization and streamlining software licensing.
Software-Defined Networking (SDN) is yet one more example of a modern approach to data center technology, this time focused on networks. SDN disassociates the routing process (control plane) from the packet-forwarding process (data plane) by spinning up virtual networks that operate alongside the underlying physical network. It enables code-driven control, centralized management, and versatile (re)configuration of hardware resources to enhance both flexibility and overall efficiency, increase performance, and drive down the implementation and operational costs of the resulting network.
Software-Defined Data Center (SDDC) is the culmination of integrating Software-Defined Storage (SDS) and Software-Defined Compute (SDC), along with Software-Defined Networking (SDN). Together, these components create a fully virtualized IT infrastructure where all key elements of a modern data center, which are storage, compute, and networking, are abstracted, pooled, scaled, and managed entirely through software.
As mentioned earlier, Hyperconverged Infrastructure, or HCI in short, combines compute, storage, and networking into a single, 100% software-defined platform that runs entirely on commodity hardware. It leverages virtualization tech to pool resources across a cluster of nodes, creating a unified system managed through a centralized software interface.
This setup eliminates the need for separate compute servers, storage arrays, and dedicated physical networks, with the software taking care of everything, which is resource allocation, failover, data replication, load balancing, telemetry collection, and even advanced monitoring to simplify support. Scaling is straightforward, ‘just drop in more nodes’, and the software automatically (re)balances and ensures redundancy.
The result is a highly available system that's resilient to both hardware and software failures, extremely easy to manage, cost-effective due to commodity hardware, and energy-efficient thanks to optimized resource utilization. On top of that, software licensing is streamlined, further improving cost efficiency.
There is a lot to take in when it comes to hyperconverged infrastructure. Like always, people like to pit concepts against each other, however, software and hardware HCI are two distinct approaches rather than alternatives.
Hardware HCI | Software HCI | |
Form | Hardware platform (appliance) | Software solution |
Intention | Storage-to-CPU ratio optimization based on business and IT infrastructure needs (balanced, performance-focused, capacity-focused, etc.) | Hardware resources virtualization for further distribution, capitalization, and optimal use (performance, resiliency, backup, etc.) |
Utilization | Deployed as is, ready-to-work data center in a compact form | Software deployment, virtualizes storage, server, or networking |
General Benefit | Great for high-intensity workload IT environments and when high hardware modularity and scalability are of the essence | Allows to gain HCI benefits and perks on available commodity hardware without buying a new appliance |
General Concern | Appliances tend to be proprietary to the HCI vendor, scalability can boil down to adding an entire new HCI node instead of granular scaling, vendor lock-in possible | Existing hardware won’t be as intentionally picked and tightly integrated as in hardware HCI, may need other software for monitoring and management |
98% of StarWind customers would definitely recommend it to other businesses based on G2’s Summer 2023 Grid® Report for HCI Solutions
in Gartner® Peer Insights: "Voice of the Customer": Hyperconverged Infrastructure
The main idea of converged infrastructure (CI) is to minimize compatibility issues between servers, storage systems, and network switching. To achieve this, a converged infrastructure delivers a set of separate compute, storage, and networking resources optimized and tested for better interoperability. While reducing the complexity of the data center IT infrastructure to a certain extent, a converged approach has significant drawbacks.
The components in a converged infrastructure are managed separately, requiring dedicated applications to manage various pieces of hardware, sometimes making administration a challenging task.
Furthermore, such infrastructures have a large hardware footprint – servers, data storage devices, and networking equipment occupy unnecessary space and convert into limited flexibility and scaling options. Additionally, due to a large amount of hardware utilized, CI implies significant deployment and operational expenses.
Here are the major benefits of HCI over a traditional data center technology:
HCI combines compute, storage, and networking into a single system managed through a unified software interface, eliminating the need to manage separate silos. In contrast, traditional data centers rely on multiple specialized hardware and software stacks, resulting in increased management complexity and higher associated costs. For example, deploying an all-flash SAN can be an extremely costly project, often requiring significant investment in specialized hardware, complex configurations, and ongoing maintenance. These expenses can quickly add up, especially when factoring in the proprietary nature of traditional SAN systems.
HCI systems are highly automated and straightforward to deploy, featuring centralized management tools for provisioning, scaling, and monitoring. In contrast, traditional setups often require lengthy manual configurations and involve multiple, often costly, experts with specialized knowledge across various domains. For instance, maintaining a Fibre Channel infrastructure isn’t just about the expensive hardware, it also requires a dedicated team to handle FC storage management, monitoring, and all the associated tasks, which adds significant operational overhead.
With HCI, scaling is as simple as adding more nodes to the cluster. Resources are automatically rebalanced, and new capacity is seamlessly integrated, and traditional infrastructures may require complex upgrades, such as expanding SANs or configuring new networking hardware. Independent scaling of compute by adding production servers, separate storage and data networks, and actual storage systems is neither simple nor cost-effective. Each component introduces additional complexity, procurement challenges, and significant expenses, making it a cumbersome approach compared to integrated solutions like HCI.
HCI leverages commodity hardware, eliminating the need for expensive proprietary servers, storage arrays, and networking devices. Power and cooling costs are also reduced due to better resource utilization. Traditional setups often rely on specialized hardware, leading to higher CapEx and OpEx. Commodity hardware is cost-effective because it benefits from mass production, driving economies of scale that keep prices low. In contrast, dedicated hardware is inherently expensive due to its low production volume and specialized nature, which cannot compete with the affordability of widely manufactured, off-the-shelf components.
HCI includes built-in redundancy and failover mechanisms, ensuring data and workloads remain available even during hardware failures, while traditional data centers may require additional components (e.g., dedicated backup systems or clustering software) to achieve the same level of resilience. Of course, the traditional approach can achieve HA as well, but with HCI, it’s all handled in a single platform. In a traditional setup, you need separate HA configurations for compute, network, and storage, adding complexity and management costs.
HCI pools resources across the entire cluster, maximizing CPU, memory, and storage utilization, and in traditional data centers, resources are often underutilized due to rigid allocation and isolated hardware silos. Separate hardware silos are inherently difficult to fully utilize due to their isolated design. Each silo operates independently, often leading to resource overprovisioning in one area while others remain underutilized, creating inefficiencies that are hard to avoid.
HCI reduces deployment times significantly, allowing organizations to roll out new workloads or applications faster. Traditional environments often involve complex procurement and configuration cycles. With traditional infrastructure, compute, storage, and networking must be deployed separately, each requiring its own setup while ensuring they all integrate seamlessly, a process that can be both time-consuming and complex. In contrast, HCI naturally combines all these elements into a single platform, providing a unified plane that simplifies deployment and management right out of the box.
HCI is highly adaptable to modern workloads, whether it’s running virtual machines, containers, or cloud-native applications, while traditional setups are less agile and may struggle to keep up with rapidly evolving application demands. While it’s certainly possible to run both virtual machines and containers on non-HCI installations, it’s significantly more challenging because scaling compute power, storage capacity, and network bandwidth must be managed separately.
Features like snapshots, replication, and disaster recovery (DR) are built into HCI solutions, making data protection straightforward. In contrast, traditional systems often require third-party software and additional hardware to achieve similar capabilities. Backup solutions provided by the HCI vendor are truly first-class citizens because the vendor has an in-depth understanding of their own system. They design backup tools that are deeply integrated, optimized, and tailored to the platform’s architecture, ensuring seamless operation and maximum efficiency compared to third-party options.
HCI is designed to integrate seamlessly with private, public, or hybrid cloud environments, supporting dynamic and scalable architectures, and traditional data centers may require significant rework to achieve similar levels of cloud integration. Public clouds are typically built on HCI-based architectures, often using the same hypervisor as on-premises HCI systems. This alignment means migrating workloads to and from the public cloud requires significantly less effort compared to moving them from a non-HCI configuration. The compatibility and uniformity of HCI streamline the process, reducing complexity and potential downtime.
Summary is, HCI simplifies operations, reduces overall costs, and delivers agility and scalability that traditional data centers can't match. It’s particularly well-suited for businesses looking to modernize their IT infrastructure, optimize management, and better handle today’s dynamic cloud-like workloads.
The most common use cases for HCI are:
HCI offers a compact, efficient solution for ROBO environments, enabling centralized management and reducing the need for extensive on-site IT resources.
HCI's flexibility and scalability make it well-suited for edge deployments, addressing challenges like limited physical space and the need for centralized management. It’s ideal for running low-demand applications on limited, available hardware, ensuring efficient resource utilization typically found in Edge environments.
HCI's scalability and performance make it perfect for VDI deployments, providing a seamless user experience and simplified management.
HCI is an excellent foundation for building an on-premises private cloud, offering reduced installation and operational costs, better efficiency, and outstanding security. Its unified platform simplifies resource provisioning and scaling, while built-in automation ensures consistent performance. With integrated data protection and robust security features, HCI delivers the reliability and control needed for private cloud environments.
HCI enables seamless operation and migration of both virtual machines and containers across on-premises data centers, public cloud, and edge environments, making it an effective hybrid cloud solution. Its unified management and software-defined architecture simplify resource allocation and scaling across platforms, while built-in automation and data protection ensure reliability and security in mixed environments.
HCI simplifies management and scales effortlessly to handle growing data while delivering high performance for demanding workloads, making it ideal for critical databases and various Big Data applications.
In general, or to summarize anything falling into these patterns, HCI excel in scenarios involving data center modernization and disaster recovery. By integrating compute, storage, and networking, hyperconvergence simplifies infrastructure while offering robust data protection features like replication and failover, ensuring scalability, reliability, and efficiency for modern IT environments.
Today, the complexity of data center IT environment is continuously growing as the amount of data increases and applications demand more compute power with more infrastructure components needed to support it.
At the same time, IT departments should always be able to provision resources instantly while maintaining flexibility and scalability of the infrastructure to handle unpredictable data growth.
Traditional data center infrastructure is comprised of separate compute, storage, and networking components requiring different administrative groups and systems for their management. The storage team, for example, handles the maintenance of the storage subsystem and the relationship with the storage hardware vendor. The same goes for the servers and the network teams.
Such infrastructures feature multiple management interfaces for separate components, higher maintenance costs, and are a real headache in terms of support since different components often come from different vendors.
All of this makes infrastructure management a highly time- and effort-consuming task forcing businesses to spend their time and money just on keeping the IT infrastructure working instead of focusing on innovations and services delivery.
StarWind has been bringing enterprise-quality storage virtualization and hyperconvergence benefits in minimalistic form to the average business for well over a decade. We don’t believe in gatekeeping and don’t practice vendor lock-in. Hyperconverged infrastructure solutions from StarWind are built to deliver white-glove HCI experience at reasonable price and minimum effort.
There are various misconceptions about hyperconverged infrastructure (HCI) from unfriendly scalability conditions and complex operability to unjustified costs and overkill requirements.
There is some truth to some of them. However, it depends on which HCI vendor you’re looking at, what your business really needs, and how best you should approach your mission-critical applications.
Under the Hood of StarWind All-Flash HyperConverged Appliance
StarWind VSAN for Hyper-V on VMware vSphere 6.5. ESXi Hosts
StarWind VSAN HCI for a 3-Node Windows Server 2016 Scenario
How VMware VSAN Really Performs by Using the HCIBench Utility
Where Microsoft Is Going with Its Innovations for Azure Stack HCI
Our products are now available at flexible subscription payments simply as part of your OpEx.